Review of the Year – 2024 – Prog Rock

2024 was a stunning year for Prog Rock new and old

The Cover of Living and Alive by Beatrix Players
The Cover of  Living & Alive by Beatrix Players

The Return of Beatrix Players

Beatrix Players, led by Ms Amy Birks, made a welcome return to the progressive rock scene in late 2023 with the release of their album Living and Alive. In 2024, they brought the complete album to Manchester’s Band on the Wall and then to a triumphant home gig in the village of Barlaston, near Stoke-on-Trent. Birks was heavily pregnant and jokingly complained of ‘baby brain’; she has since given birth to a baby daughter. In the meantime, Birks and her band were superb live. Birks was a charismatic leader, her wonderfully expressive voice ranging from a warm, low mezzo to a high soprano, sometimes urgent in her delivery and at other times quietly intimate – often in the same song. She was a powerful stage presence, drawing the audience in, as their enthusiastic response showed. 

Myrkur - image by Gobinder Jhitta
Amalie Bruun (Myrkur)

Myrkur – Danish Black Metal and Scandinavian folk music

The Danish composer, vocalist, and classically trained multi-instrumentalist Amalie Bruun released her debut album under her own name in 2006. In 2011, she formed the indie pop duo Ex Cops with Brian Harding. The band split in 2014, and she started releasing music under the name Myrkur, Icelandic for darkness. In late 2023, she released Spine, which combines many of the styles of previous albums into a sophisticated whole, graced by her remarkably versatile voice. The album was partly based on her experience of being pregnant with her son Otto, who was born in 2019.

But the song My Blood is Gold, reviewed here in the ongoing Off the Beaten Track series, is a product of another significant life event: the death of her beloved father, Michael Bruun, in 2021. This profoundly moving track perfectly describes Bruun’s despair at her father’s death and her resolve for his memory to live on through her music.

Bruun brought her music to London in April 2024, demonstrating her versatility as a singer and songwriter in an eclectic set. Over the course of four albums and various EPs and singles, she has combined black metal with Scandinavian folk music, sometimes on the same album. Her latest album, Spine, her most eclectic yet, formed the bulk of the setlist, including a run of six songs at the start of the show. Bruun was joined on stage by Swedish folk singer Jonathan Hultén, the support act, in a gorgeous version of House Carpenter, a traditional Nordic folk song, attracting the most excited applause of the evening.

The front cover of SIRIN by Marjana Semkina
Marjana Semkina on the cover of her second solo album, SIRIN

Marjana Semkina and iamthemorning – a difficult but artistically successful year

Marjana Semkina is a member of the prog rock group iamthemorning with her Russian-born compatriot, the pianist Gleb Kolyadin, both of whom are now resident in the UK. The duo have released several records, the most recent being The Bell (2019) and the EP Counting The Ghosts (2020).

Semkina has recently pursued a parallel solo career, releasing her first solo LP, Sleepwalking, in 2020 and her EP, Disillusioned, in 2021. In 2024 she sang on the Moonflower EP with Zora Cock of Blackbriar, and released SIRIN, her second solo album. Semkina created this album without the support of a record label, raising tens of thousands of pounds for the project via crowd funding. She is an exceptional talent, as a singer and a songwriter, and a passionate promoter of her poetic and profound vision of the world through her music.

Semkina had a challenging year. Her bandmate Kolyadin was arrested and imprisoned in Thailand while on tour as a session musician with the Russian dissident rock band Bi-2. He faced deportation to Russia, where the band could have been persecuted for anti-war sentiments. Semkina highlighted the story via social media and an online petition.

Kolyadin was released after a week in prison and returned to England via Israel. A few days after his release, the duo performed an emotional comeback show at Piano Smithfield in London. Later in the year, the duo were joined by a full band to perform iamthemorning songs at St. Matthias Church in Stoke Newington, London. Semkina began with an evocative selection of her solo material, and Kolyadin demonstrated his supreme skill as an improviser in a solo piano set before the iamthemorning band played a superb band set.

The Cover of Harmonic Divergence by Steven Wilson

An Overview of Steven Wilson’s Year

While fans of Steven Wilson eagerly await his new album The Overview due in March, in 2024 he released a Record Store Day album Harmonic Divergence based on his 2023 album The Harmony Codex. Producer Ewan Pearson also remixed ‘Inclination’ from that album. Alexis Petridis of The Guardian wrote, ‘Ewan Pearson sprinkles sunlit Balearic euphoria’, and Wilson described the remix as ‘a hypnotic cosmic disco odyssey.’

The year also saw the re-release of Storm Corrosion, the collaboration between Wilson and Mikael Åkerfeldt of Swedish progressive metal band Opeth, in a new Dolby Atmos remix. Wilson has been making surround mixes of his own and other bands’ albums for so long now that he has been asked to do a surround sound mix of King Crimson’s Red for the second time after he did his first surround mix of the album in 2009. He decided to teach himself the art of surround sound mixing after Elliot Scheiner created 5.1 mixes of the Porcupine Tree albums In Absentia and Deadwing.

As Mikael Åkerfeldt admitted, Storm Corrosion isn’t an easy listen. However, it is certainly not as challenging to listen to as the albums Wilson has produced for his Bass Communion project, such as Ghosts on Magnetic Tape. Both albums take a while to give up their secrets and bring joy to the listener. In the Dolby Atmos mix of Storm Corrosion, the opening track makes the most startling use of the new technology. On other tracks, the effect is more muted, but when surround sound is used, it’s more effective as it is used sparingly.

Finally, in 2024, Wilson brought festive greetings to his fans with a physical release of his 2023 Christmas song, December Skies, complete with two Wilson-themed Christmas cards. The year also marked the fifth anniversary of the release of love you to bits, Wilson’s album with his no-man bandmate Tim Bowness, a melancholy disco masterpiece.                                        

Cover of Perpetual Motions by Gavin Harrison and Antoine Fafard
Perpetual Motions by Gavin Harrison and Antoine Fafard

Perpetual Change with Gavin Harrison and Antoine Fafard

Gavin Harrison, the drummer in Steven Wilson’s band Porcupine Tree, released Perpetual Motions, his second album with bass player Antoine Fafard, a collection of inventive musical explorations and collaborations from the virtuosic duo and several friends. The album’s title describes the perpetual change of musical arrangement from one of Fafard’s compositions to the next, the only constant being the playing of Fafard and Harrison on every piece. Remarkably, Fafard presented Harrison with complete recordings to add drums and percussion later; Harrison’s playing perfectly matches the pieces so it’s impossible to tell that his recordings were done separately. 

Malcolm Galloway and Mark Gatland
Malcolm Galloway and Mark Gatland of Hats Off Gentlemen It’s Adequate

Malcolm Galloway had a more than Adequate Year

Malcolm Galloway of Hats Off Gentlemen It’s Adequate provided deep insights into his health condition and his writing process in a fascinating two-part interview: Part One and Part Two are here. Galloway and his bandmate Mark Gatland have a new album out in March, The Uncertainty Principle. In the meantime, One Word That Means The World (Arkhipov), one of the singles from the album, was released in 2024. It’s a compelling snapshot of a moral dilemma in which one man’s brave decision probably averted World War III. Hats Off shared the bill in Camden, London with a new discovery for me, the band EBB, who have a wonderful stage presence.

Prog the Forest at the Fiddler’s Elbow

Malcolm Galloway and Mark Gatland, with the promoter London Prog Gigs, hosted a charity prog festival, Prog the Forest, at the Fiddler’s Elbow in Camden. All performers gave their services for free to support the rainforest and wildlife conservation charity, World Land Trust, which ‘protects the world’s most biologically significant and threatened habitats.’ This was the sixth year of Prog the Forest and the most successful to date, raising £2750 to protect nearly 26 acres of rainforest and other threatened habitats.

The eclectic line-up was made up of: Spriggan Mist, a ‘pagan progressive rock band’; singer-songwriter Leoni Jane Kennedy, who was hand-picked by members of Queen for the Freddie Mercury Scholarship and plays acoustic Rush covers as well as her own songs; The Mighty Handful who include a ‘former music director of Strictly; Mountainscape who play instrumental post-metal; Theo Travis of Soft Machine, who has played saxophone and flute with numerous jazz and prog bands; Tim Bowness and Butterfly Mind; and Hats Off Gentlemen It’s Adequate.

Nick Mason's Saucerful of Secrets at Manchester Apollo
Nick Mason’s Saucerful of Secrets

Prog History Brought to Life

The late 1960s to the mid-1970s were arguably the golden era of Prog Rock, particularly in the UK, but as can be seen from the reviews above, the genre continues to thrive, with superb new music being produced both on record and live.

New life has also been breathed into prog rock classics, with the return of Nick Mason’s Saucerful of Secrets with live interpretations of early Pink Floyd songs. Robin A Smith continued to tour Mike Oldfield’s Tubular Bells – the 50th anniversary, with a stunning new arrangement of the classic album; 2024 was also the 50th anniversary of the release of Peter Hammill’s solo album The Silent Corner and the Empty Stage, from which the epic track ‘A Louse is not a Home‘ is taken.

Special Thanks

With thanks to Jerry Ewing and Prog magazine for keeping the prog flag flying, and to Chris Parkins of London Prog Gigs for his tireless contribution to the live scene in London.

For an overview of the year in classical music in 2024, click here.

Mike Oldfield’s Tubular Bells – 50th Anniversary European Tour – Live Review

The Tubular Bells band

Tuesday 22 October 2024

The Bridgewater Hall Manchester

*****

A joyous re-imagining of a 20th century classic

Tubular Bells 50th Anniversary Concert

The History of Tubular Bells

Mike Oldfield’s Tubular Bells, released on 25 March 1973, made a slow start. It didn’t enter the UK album charts until 14 July 1973, and then only at a lowly number 31. It wasn’t until after the release of the horror film The Exorcist in December 1973, which featured the opening piano motif of Oldfield’s piece as its theme tune, that the album became a massive worldwide success. It remained in the UK top ten for a year from March 1974 and peaked at no. 1 on 5 October of that year. In total, it has spent over five years in the UK top 100. The cover artwork, shot by the English photographer Trevor Key shared an iconic simplicity with Pink Floyd’s The Dark Side of the Moon, which was released a few weeks earlier. Both album covers, with their classic triangular designs found their way into millions of British homes in the 1970s and beyond. In 2010, the cover of Tubular Bells was featured as one of ten Royal Mail stamps with famous British album covers, along with Pink Floyd’s The Division Bell (1994).

“There was Sibelius in it, there was Debussy in it. It was all of the best bits of music I’d ever heard.”

Tom Newman, Tubular Bells Producer, on the original demo tape

Recording Tubular Bells

Oldfield wrote the album in his late teens and recorded virtually all the instrumental parts himself at the Manor Studio in Oxfordshire. It was the first release on Richard Branson’s record label, launching the Virgin brand. The album was recorded on Virgin’s 16-track tape reel-to-reel recorder, with Oldfield over-dubbing multiple instruments. Oldfield’s Producer, Tom Newman described the album as ‘minimalist’ music. It was partly inspired by the track ‘A Rainbow in Curved Air’ from Terry Riley’s 1969 album of the same name. Newman said that Oldfield, rather than using tape loops as Riley did, instead played each loop by hand to avoid a mechanical feel. The first side of the album ends with the English singer-songwriter, musician, author, and poet Vivian Stanshall introducing several of the instruments that Oldfield played, ending with the tubular bells. This passage is reminiscent of The Young Person’s Guide to the Orchestra (1945) by Benjamin Britten in which an announcer introduces various sections of the orchestra.

Live Performances

Oldfield first performed the full album live in concert at the Queen Elizabeth Hall (QEH) in London on 25 June 1973. He was very reluctant to perform, and only did so because Branson gave him his Bentley which had belonged to George Harrison. Many of the musicians who played in the QEH concert joined Oldfield again for a studio recording of the piece on 30 November 1973, which was broadcast on BBC 2 television on 5 January 1974.

The fiftieth anniversary celebrations began in August 2021 when there was a run of concerts at the Queen Elizabeth Hall. Oldfield wasn’t involved with those concerts, having retired from live performance. They were directed by the arranger, composer and conductor Robin A. Smith, who first met Oldfield in Los Angeles in 1991.

“There’s no question that Tubular Bells is one of the most unique pieces of music written [in the 20th] century. It embraces so many platforms. It is highly complex, embracing  minimalist, rock, serialisation, and in many ways heralded the emergence of new age music; chill and ambient.”

Robin A. Smith,
robin-smith.co.uk

Smith was introduced to Mike Oldfield by Mike’s sister, Sally Oldfield, when he was working as a session musician on her 1990 album Natasha. Smith worked with Oldfield on the world premiere of the 1992 album Tubular Bells II at Edinburgh Castle, on Tubular Bells III (1998), and on a live performance of The Millennium Bell (1999) in Berlin on New Year’s Eve 1999. The last time Smith and Oldfield played live together was at the opening ceremony of the London Olympics in 2012.

Oldfield’s live performances of Tubular Bells in 1973 stuck fairly closely to the original recording, but for the 50th anniversary Smith has enhanced the original by adding extra ‘cinematic textures.’ As he said in the Tubular Bells 50th Anniversary Tour Documentary (2022),

‘There will be many people who come here and go, ‘it doesn’t sound anything like the record”.

Fans of the original record who attended the concert on Tuesday evening in Manchester needn’t have worried – Smith is a consummate arranger, and has even been nominated for a Grammy for his skills in this department. And he was joined by a superb live band who did full justice to his arrangements – which were rich and orchestral in style – and to the spirit of Oldfield’s music.

The First Half of the Concertfrom Ommadawn to Discovery and a shiny Gem

Robin A Smith and Jay Stapley
Robin A Smith and Jay Stapley

The first half began with the opposite of Haydn’s Farewell Symphony (1772), in which the players gradually leave the stage until only two violinists are left. Each performer came on stage individually, starting with Smith who was the evening’s Musical Director, pianist and keyboard player. The opening sequence, played as a continuous medley, consisted of instrumental themes from Tubular Bells II, Ommadawn (1975)/Return to Ommadawn (2017), the song ‘To France‘ (from Discovery 1984) and the instrumental Summit Day (from Guitars 1999). Smith was joined in the lovely contemplative, opening section by Maxime Obideau on acoustic guitar then Jay Stapley on sweet-toned Fender Strat. The track built to a nostalgic, bluesy solo.

Lisa Featherston, who played bass for most of the concert, provided soulful vocals in a lovely arrangement of ‘To France’. Percussionists Jack Davies and Will Miles and cellist Kwesi Edman soon joined, and the band was completed by vocalist Daisy Bevan. At this point it’s worth mentioning the stunning contribution of Bevan throughout the evening. She trained as a soprano with Sara Fulgoni and Mary Plazas at the Royal Northern Collage of Music in Manchester and has performed at opera houses around the world. Her wordless vocalising throughout the evening was stunning, sometimes full-throated and operatic, sometimes soulful, at other times gentle and wistful.

Featherston also sang lead vocals on Moonlight Shadow, Oldfield’s most popular single, which reached number four in the UK in 1983, and number one in several European countries. This was a rockier version than the folk-tinged original, with heavy, rumbling drums giving it more momentum, and a lovely, fluid guitar solo from Jay Stapley. He also provided vocals on a rocky version of Family Man, which reached number 15 in the UK singles charts in 1982.

Maxime Obideau playing Mandolin
Maxime Obideau. Image © Manuel Harlan

The highlight of the first half was Robin Smith’s composition The Gem from Tubular Bells Reimagined released on bandcamp in January of this year. This instrumental epic began with atmospheric electronics, some gorgeous slide guitar work from Maxime Obideau, and resonant bass from Lisa Featherston. A plaintive cello solo from Kwesi Edman led to the sonorous main theme, which was reminiscent of the piano theme from another epic prog track, ‘Storm Corrosion’ from the 2012 album of that name by Steven Wilson and Mikael Åkerfeldt of Opeth. Will Miles and Jack Davies on percussion, including timpani, played elemental, cinematic rhythms. Smith’s piece had some lovely key changes, and an uplifting sense of musical inevitability. The second section was lighter and more folky, with glowingly optimistic keyboards, mandolin and a nice flowing bass line. A cello solo and a piano solo brought a beautiful moment of stillness before the final section with warm wordless vocals from Daisy Bevan, which may have reminded some listeners of Clare Torry’s gorgeous wordless vocals on ‘The Great Gig in the Sky’ from The Dark Side of the Moon. And Stapley’s guitar solo was suitably Floydian. After some heavy, military drumming and further epic key changes, the song ended with an affecting piano coda from Smith. A stunning finale to the first half of the concert.

The Second Half of the Concert – Tubular Bells

The second half was devoted to Tubular Bells. Part I began with low earthy electronics, and a synthesised ethereal choir before the distinctive opening piano theme appeared, to applause from the audience, played by Obideau, and doubled by Stapley’s guitar as Bevan’s voice soared above. A transitional section led to a duet between mandolin and a solo by Kwesi Edman, whose lyrical playing was a delight. A visceral heavy rock section saw the two guitarists coming to the front of the stage, and they soon returned to play a lovely blues duet, with an intricate but funky syncopated section. Smith played honky-tonk piano, smiling beatifically. His calm but enthusiastic presence was a joy to behold. There was more funk with thundering drums, leading to a single repeated note played on the tubular bells which took pride of place at the rear centre of the stage amongst the massed ranks of percussion instruments. A precisely picked acoustic guitar solo led to a heavy metal guitar passage, with funky guitar and a bouncing bass line in unison, and delicate chords from Obideau. There was a sense of anticipation as the music built up to a climax in the closing section where various instruments from the band were introduced by the recorded voice of Sam West. After all the drama, Part I ended with a solo acoustic guitar. There was a well-deserved standing ovation.

Kwesi Edman playing cello
Kwesi Edman. Image © Manuel Harlan

Part II of Tubular Bells began with shimmering electronics, with a spacey almost psychedelic feel as Obideau on mandolin picked out the first theme and Bevan sang tender vocals. A transitional passage led to a pastoral, folky section with added percussion, the musicians smiling in rapturous concentration. Edman played a graceful cello solo with a heartfelt melody. Bevan brought operatic drama to another transition passage, which led to a joyful, folky reel on double guitars with soaring guitars and stirring percussion.

The next section on the original album featured Oldfield’s strange vocal section in which he grunted, growled and shouted in the voice of a cavemen he christened Piltdown Man after the early 20th century fraud in which the remains of ‘early man’ were allegedly found in Piltdown, East Sussex. Oldfield told Richard Buskin of Sound on Sound that, ‘Back then, I was absolutely useless as a vocalist and as a lyricist, and I actually damaged my larynx doing that part.’ The story goes that he only added it at the suggestion of Richard Branson and others who thought that the album needed some vocals. Perhaps wisely, the vocals, which were recorded, were placed very low in the mix in Smith’s version, allowing the two guitarists to shine with double prog metal solos, joined by thunderous drums. Obideau, in full rock star mode, played a stunning solo which drew applause from the audience. Another solo from Edman led to another pastoral section which could have been written by an early 20th century English composer like Frederick Delius. The two guitarists continued to show their versatility with a Floydian solo from Stapley and a psychedelic solo from Obideau, and Smith traversed the keyboard with jazzy flourishes. Bevan came to the front of the stage for a well-deserved solo spot. The piece ended with the full band playing a thunderous repeated chord in true rock’n’roll style. Another standing ovation ensued.

The Tubular Bells band
The band acknowledge a standing ovation from the audience

A Jolly Encore

The encore was a witty and joyful version of the traditional piece The Sailor’s Hornpipe, which has become a staple of The Last Night of Proms, complete with audience participation. Stapley encouraged the audience on Tuesday to ‘clap at will’ as the music got faster and faster. There was yet another standing ovation.

A Joyful Performance

The original Tubular Bells was the product of superb musicianship, a fertile imagination and many hours spent in the studio painstakingly overdubbing everything by hand, the product of a singular vision. Robin Smith’s stunning arrangement paid fitting tribute to the original but added drama and cinematic touches to produce a compelling new version. He was joined by an excellent ensemble of virtuoso musicians who performed with joy and dedication, delighting a packed Bridgewater Hall.

Performers

Robin A Smith – Keyboards/Piano/Musical Director
Jay Stapley – Guitar
Maxime Obideau – Guitar and Mandolin
Lisa Featherston – Bass
Kwesi Edman – Cello
Daisy (Anastasia) Bevan – Vocals
Will Miles – Percussion
Jack Davies – Percussion
Sam West – Recorded Narration on Tubular Bells Part I

Sources

Robin Smith’s website
Tubular Bells 50th Anniversary Tour Documentary
Official Tour website
The Official UK Albums Chart
Michaels, Sean, Coldplay album gets stamp of approval from Royal Mail (The Guardian 8 January 2010)
Buskin, Richard, Classic Tracks: Mike Oldfield ‘Tubular Bells’ (Sound on Sound April 2013)

Tubular Bells continues touring, with 13 more dates in England until 12 November and a European tour in March – April 2025

This article was corrected at 16.24 on Tuesday 29 October to confirm that the percussionists were Will Miles and Jack Davies. Tom Marsden played percussion on a previous tour.